For the ladies, a choice between two guys if they approached you but not at the same time?

Out of these two guys which one would you pick and why?

Guy 1 is a hot and sexy narcissistic bad boy who doesn't reveal that he is like that at first until later on in the relationship where he gets comfortable, a bit of a dum dum, confidence built from women throwing themselves at him and telling him he's sexy as well as several one night stands, a dude bro, he has a horrible personality but is a smooth sweet talker with women, he uses his looks to get women, he lives in a house with other guys who are like him, he drives a beater, and he works in retail

Guy 2 is unattractive, he's a good guy, confidence built from success, he's intelligent, he's a geek who likes video games, anime, sci-fi, comic books, and other geek culture, doesn't really gets into relationships as much or at all, has a good personality, not much of a smooth talker but still tries to be, doesn't use looks or money but instead charming wit and intelligence, lives in a two bedroom apartment by himself, drives a 2010 Honda accord, and works I a factory that pays well.

Narcissist is a complete turnoff. And the 'uses women' means STD infested.

Geek is no longer a 'bad thing' you realize.

Well, I happen to like nerdy guys more in general. Most of the time they are sweet and hilarious. So I'd probably go with guy #2

#2 easily

Women say guy #2 but in reality women would go with guy #1 f he came up to them. He's the stereotypical hot and sexy bad boy that women can't resist which means he's thrilling, adventurous, and knows how to have a good time in the eyes of women. Even if he is narcissistic he won't reveal that till later on in the relationship and she'll think it's her fault and stay with him hoping she can change him, they're not gonna see that and immediately dump him because she'll wonder if she can do better and according to women doing better is finding another hot guy. Even if she does dump him she already has another hot guy lined up and it makes it worse he's a smooth sweet talker so he'll just keep reeling her in. The unattractive guy however only has personality which to women isn't enough and she'll just make him her friend because he's unattractive however since he has money she'll just settle for him when they're older and that's if he's single. Women say one thing and do the opposite.

Christopher is so full of s**t.

I'm a grown woman and I'd choose the second guy any day. I don't deal with self-absorbed people any day nor do I have any tolerance for a man who uses women. He may look hot, but that's about all he's good for. Real women want real men, not a**holes who have no respect for women.

In theory I think most girls would say guy no. 2 BUT in reality they wouldn't know all that info, and if introduced to both then I imagine most would pick guy 1. Knowing all that information if probably say neither to be honest