Recommendations for a reliable, good on gas college commuter that will hold its resale value?

Need some advice. I just sold my mustang as it was not my idea of a good commuter car. I would like to go strictly good on gas and reliable.

I'm thinking about the Honda Civic SI, Honda Accord or a Toyota Tacoma (I ride dirt bikes)

Any other recommendations? The civic si seems fun, and they have an awesome aftermarket.

If you're looking strictly for fuel mileage, then look at the VW Golf with the turbo diesel (TDI) engine

The Tesla Model S holds the record for holding its value. No fuel. Tell me, what is "I" followed by an "m?" This has no meaning in English. Honda Civic. Mustang. You seem to have neglected to capitalize these proper names.