2016 Honda Pilot or Odyssey for family?

My parents are looking for a new car to replace their 2003 Honda Odyssey, which they bought new. We're a family of five but rarely have all five of us in the van at one time, as we all have our own separate living situations. I guess you could say they are sort of empty nesters, so they don't necessarily need to have a big 8 passenger minivan anymore. They are stuck between the new Pilot or the new Odyssey.

The good thing about the Pilot is that it is smaller and easier to drive than a minivan while still holding good cargo capacity, however there are indeed a few occasions out of the year where they need to cram 5+ people into the minivan. The van has proven to be very useful those few times when they truly need the space. Seems like SUV third rows are very uncomfortable and practically useless whereas minivan third rows are as comfortable as any other seat in the car. Pilot is just an easier car to live with, Odyssey is more versatile. What do you suggest?

Added (1). both leases

Neither! An purchase of a new vehicle is foolish because the moment that one tire leaves the dealer's lot, the vehicle will lose thousands of $$ in value! Much better to get a slightly used 2015

Sounds to me that you've already answered that you should get the Pilot over an Odyssey that you would have less and less need for.

They are grown adults, why are you meddling in their affairs, let them make the decision. It's THEIR money, NOT YOURS!

  • 2016 MINI Cooper Hardtop 4 Door or 2016 Honda Fit for first car? I love cute and comfy. Mostly just to get to and from work at Disney, but I'm also a big traveler so would love something comfy and cozy that sort of resembles my personality (I know- I'm cheesy) I know nothing about cars and this will be my first! I'm 19 and have waited to get my license for way too long so I'm working on it in Driving 101 and should take the test next month!
  • Should I get a 2016 Honda CR-V EX AWD or a 2016 Subaru Crosstrek 2.1i Limited? I'm trying to decide between the two. They are both the same price at my dealers. I'm probably going to end up moving to Colorado but I don't think I will go off road at all. Which of these is the better car? Which do you think will last longer?
  • Which car is better, the 2016 Honda Civic EX-T or the 2016 Mazda 6 i sport? I'm getting a new car next month, and my choices have been cut down to these two cars. I'm having difficulty deciding. Which one is better? Please list spec differences (exterior and interior) as well as the reasoning behind your decision.
  • Which car is better 2016 Honda Civic coupe or 2016 Hyundai Genesis coupe? I'm looking for a new car and these two are the only cars that fit my budge as a sporty car. The Honda Civic has a v cylinder engin and Genesis has v6. Civic offers Apple car play whereas Genesis does not… They both have many pors and cons to them and I can't decide which one is better and worthwhile… Please I need opinions!