Car not starting after cold day?

I own a 2009 Honda Civic, that has, in the past 2 years never had an issue. 2 months ago, battery went bad, replaced it, everything was great. Until last week. Suddenly, if I leave the car out in the cold for a few hours, it won't even try to start. Takes a 10 second jump to get it going again, then it works perfectly for a few days. Any ideas what might be the issue? Advanced auto parts ran diagnostics on the starter, alternator, Anne battery, all good.

Try cleaning the battery terminals.