How much should a catalytic converter cost to replace?

I recently failed my smog check for my 1998 Honda civic so I took it into a shop to get it looked at. They said the catalytic converter needed to be replaced. When I asked how much it would be they said the price like twenty one fourty seven. Thinking that they meant $21.47 rather than$2,147 I told them to go ahead and replace it. I know it was dumb to think that it would be so cheap but I thought they were just saying that's how much the part was not including the labor or something. I'm 20 years old and know next to nothing about cars. Anyway today when they called me to tell me it was ready he said it like 21.47 again but right when I was hanging up he goes so 2 thousand one hundred forty seven dollars. So I'm wondering how much should it cost to replace a catalic converter including labor and everything? I don't have $2100 to spend on a car that's not even worth that much and would never have agreed for them to do the work if they hadn't been misleading about the price.

How is it that the mechanic failed to provide a written estimate?

And yes, you are at fault for not having a clue that catalytic converters are not twenty dollar parts. Buyer Beware, you flunked that.

Not that much. If you didn't sign electronically. Say you never approved the work to be done. They can get phone approval but you could make them put the old cat back on, they don't have physical proof(signature). I wouldn't want to be that technician who puts that back on.

Didn't we see this identical question (with the identical price) three or four years ago?

Answer: Yes, we did. Only it was Amanda rather than Sam.

Next time, don't fail a smog test. Fail a poiygraph test. It's likely to be cheaper.

What state are you in? If it's California, that could explain it. California emissions equipped vehicles use different converters than 49 state models, than can be MUCH more expensive. Also, if the car was built with California emissions the same rules would apply. I'll give you an example. The converter for an Astro I had was $89. A guy I worked with had the same van, but a California model. He needed a converter, it was $1500. The whole and only converter assembly on the car I have now is $240. If it was a California model there would be three converters that would cost around $2300 to replace. These are raw parts prices, not shop prices with labor. So the price they gave you may not be off the mark. At this point I'm not sure what you should do. You should have listened closer to what he said, there's no way you're taking a car to a shop and paying $21 for anything.

  • How much should it cost to replace ignition? I own a honda prelude 1999, when i go to start it the dash lights turn on and the radio and i can turn the key which starts it but when i turn the key back to the position it would drive in the car shuts off. Also sometimes when i'm driving it stalls when it shouldn't. Do i need a new ignition or is it something else and if so how much would it cost in a mechanic shop to be fixed? And how much would it cost to just buy an ignition and do it myself?
  • Can I separate a 2000 Honda Civic EX exhaust manifold from its catalytic converter? Just learned that I have a crack in the exhaust manifold of my 2000 Honda Civic EX. I could buy a new manifold with a attached catalytic converter for about $170 but could get a used manifold for $12. I would rather save myself the $100+ by just replacing the manifold. So my question is would I be able to separate the exhaust manifold from the catalytic converter, and switch in a functional but used one?
  • Why is my catalytic converter smoking? 1993 Honda Accord LX (F22a1) 4AT At idle the car is about 1500 rpm cold all the way up until warm. But at idle it vibrates a little, with the air on idle drops to 500rpm and the car shakes violently. Also my dizzy is leaking oil. Every so often the engine has a sputter or misfire. Light light pinging noise. I'm sure it's out of time. My ignition anyway. I smell gas when the car is off and after driving it my catalytic converter is smoking. Really stumped here.
  • How much should I sell a catalytic converter for? I have a 98 Honda Accord and trying to sell it. A lot of people are asking to buy just the catalytic converter. How do I know how much to sell it for? I see a bunch of different prices online.