Do Honda Civic Si Coupes cost more to insure?

I thought they did since they're technically considered a performance vehicle, but there's a 2006 Honda Civic Si Coupe that I'm interested in purchasing, so I decided to get a quote from my current insurer (I have Geico). It was actually $2.50 cheaper than my current 6 month premium with my 2002 Saturn. I even entered the VIN for the Honda, so they know it's an si, do you think that seems accurate?

It has to be a mistake… The Ins is based on the value of the car… A 2006 Honda Civic is worth more than a 2002 Saturn. I would call again.